Mendeley
TY  _  JOUR
ID  -  1401020636756
TI  -  An Analytic Critique of the Reductionist Approach to Islamic Philosophy
JO  -  History of Philasophy
JA  -  ES
LA  -  fa
SN  -  2008-9589
AU  -  mazaheri zahra
AU  -  alavi mohammadkazem
AD  -  
AD  -  عضو هیأت علمی گروه فلسفه و حکمت اسلامی، دانشگاه حکیم سبزواری، سبزوار، ایران
Y1  -  2023
PY  -  2023
VL  -  1
IS  -  
SP  -  37
EP  -  66
KW  -  Islamic philosophy
KW  -   relationship between religion and philosophy
KW  -   Greek philosophy
KW  -   Islamic theology and Kalām
KW  -   Arabic philosophy
DO  -  
N2  -  One of the recent debates regarding Islamic philosophy focuses on its originality and the questions of the “possibility of Islamic philosophy”. This identity-related problem has a significant effect on the history and future of Islamic philosophy. The view of the opponents of the originality of this denomination, including Orientalists, Western historiographers, some Arab scholars, and those who are against any kind of religious philosophy can be considered to be reductionist. In their theories, they have reduced Islamic philosophy to a philosophy imitating Greek philosophy, Islamic Kalām and theology, and Arabic philosophy. Opposing Orientalists and historiographers view Greek philosophy as the base and Islamic philosophy as one of its branches. Some of the opponents believe that any attempt at establishing Islamic philosophy is in vain by insisting on the incompatibility of religion and philosophy. Moreover, by rejecting the possibility of religious philosophy, including Islamic philosophy, they maintain that the use of the word Islamic as an adjective for philosophy, as an intellectual science, is not justified and, thus, equate Islamic philosophy with Kalām and theology. Some other opponents, including Arabs, avoid the use of the phrase “Islamic philosophy”, and, by emphasizing the language of philosophical texts in Islamic tradition, call it Arabic philosophy. They limit Arabic philosophy to the Arab race and believe that this view is supported by history of philosophy. The present paper provides a critical analysis of the proponents of reductionist approaches to Islamic philosophy and aims to demonstrate and defend the necessity of its originality as a historical reality.
UR  - rimag.ir/en/Article/36756
L1  - rimag.ir/en/Article/Download/36756
ER  -  
